Geometrical versus analytical approach in problem solving---an exploratory study
Magdalena Lemańska, Ingrid Semanišinová,
Carlos Soneira Calvo, María José Souto Salorio, Ana Dorotea Tarr\'ı o Tobar
Abstract
In this study we
analyse the geometrical visualization as a part of the process of
solution. In total 263 students in the first year of study at
three different universities in three different countries (Poland,
Slovakia and Spain) were asked to solve four mathematical
problems. The analysis of the results of all students showed that
geometrical visualization for problems where there is a
possibility to choose different ways of solving is not as frequent
as one would expect even if the problem is hardly solvable without
it. Especially Spanish students prefer to solve the problem
analytically. Visual reasoning is mostly regarded as an intuitive,
preliminary stage in the reasoning processes and nothing needs to
be done to develop it. On the basis of our results we consider it
necessary to regain the use of geometry in the classroom and
encourage visualization, the use of the figure, the physical and
spatial intuition.
Keywords: Geometrical arguments; analytical arguments; visualization; problem solving.